Easy Sugar Cookie Cutouts – No Chill, No Spread

5
(9)
Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links, and I may receive a small commission should you purchase any linked products – just know I never link anything I don’t personally use and love! I’ve got you, friend.

Classic Sugar Cookies Cutouts

There’s something timeless and magical about sugar cookie cutouts. The dough is simple. The shapes are fun. The decorating possibilities? Endless. Whether it’s snowflakes in December, hearts in February, or pumpkins in October, sugar cookie cutouts have become a must-have tradition in our kitchen.

But let’s be honest: not all sugar cookie experiences are Pinterest-perfect. Maybe you’ve tried making them before, only to end up with cookies that puffed up, lost their shape, or turned out dry and bland. We’ve all been there.

Good news: my fool-proof sugar cookie cutout recipe changes that!

Simple stack of sugar cookie cutouts

Sugar Cookie Cutouts

This is the recipe that started it all! I started making these  cookies during the pandemic to bring some joy to a very strange holiday season. I remember telling Gene my idea, and hoping that I might sell 10 cookies kits that year. I ended up selling over 100!

Classic Sugar Cookie Cutouts

Since then, my little  cookie biz has only grown more. I’ve made over 8,000 of these cookies between cookie kits, private orders, school parties, and more. AND I’ve met so many fantastic people from my community, simply through cookie kits! I’ve loved seeing these cookies incorporated into your family traditions and getting to enjoy all your pictures of your families decorating cookies together.

BUT – no gate-keeping here! I’m ready to spill ALL my baking secrets (and the real secret is that these cookies are not difficult to make). I’m going to show you step-for-step how I’ve made every single one of those 8,000 cookies, and I hope you give it a go in your own kitchen!

And the instructions are correct – do not chill this dough!

Sugar Cookie Cutouts – Icing with Cream Cheese Frosting

Easy Sugar Cookie Cutouts – No Spread!

This recipe is SO reliable and turns out perfectly every time. My favorite part is that this dough never spreads. It doesn’t matter what shape you cut your dough into – you will have the same shape after baking!

Recipe Notes

  • This recipe makes 36 large cookie cutouts. Feel free to cut this recipe in half if you need fewer cookies!
  • I have made several variations of this recipe – including cookies for Christmas, Halloween, Easter, and even have added sprinkles – see my Sprinkle Sugar Cookie Recipe!
  • You can make other variations by playing with food coloring and various extracts. Check out this Strawberry Sugar Cookie Cutout version too!
Valentine’s Day Sprinkle Sugar Cookie Cutouts
Easter Sprinkle Sugar Cookie Cutouts
Christmas Sugar Cookie Cutouts

Essential Tips for Perfect Christmas Sugar Cookies

1. Use Room Temperature Ingredients

For a smooth dough that’s easy to work with, always use room-temperature butter and eggs. Cold butter can cause the dough to be crumbly and hard to roll out.

2. Don’t Overmix the Dough

When combining the wet and dry ingredients, mix until just combined. Overworking the dough will result in tough cookies.

3. Flour Your Work Surface (But Don’t Overdo It)

While rolling out the dough, make sure to lightly flour your work surface, rolling pin, and cookie cutters. However, too much flour can dry out the dough and make the cookies too tough. Keep it light and dust off any excess.

4. Almond Emulsion

One really important note – if all you have is almond extract then that will work just fine. But let me tell you – LorAnn almond emulsion takes these cookies to the next level! This baker emulsion is truly the best – it has such a delicious, rich almond flavor. LorAnn bakery emulsions and extracts are one of my kitchen staples.

Ingredients

  1. 2 cups unsalted butter, room temperature
  2. 2 cups granulated sugar
  3. 2 eggs
  4. 1 Tbsp almond emulsion (or your extract of choice)
  5. 4 tsp baking powder
  6. 6 cups all purpose flour

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
  2. Start by creaming together your butter and sugar in your electric mixer with the paddle attachment.
  3. Once butter and sugar is light and fluffy, add in eggs and almond emulsion, mix until combined.
  4. Add in your baking powder, then add flour 2 cups at a time. Mix well each time you add flour.
  5. When you’ve added your last 2 cups of flour, the dough may be stiff. You may need to take it out of your bowl and mix by hand.
  6. Once dough is completely combined, lightly dust a clean work surface with flour and roll out your dough. I like to work with about 1/4 of the dough at a time. If you work with too much at one time it will be difficult to roll out.
  7. Roll dough to about 1/4-1/2 inch thickness and cut with desired cookie cutters
  8. Transfer to baking sheet, and bake for 6-7 minutes, depending on oven and preference. I never bake mine longer than 7 minutes. If the edges are starting to turn golden brown you’ve baked a little too long!
  9. Cool completely before decorating.
Simple stack of sugar cookie cutouts

As always, let me know if you give these a try! I would love to hear your feedback!

Print

Easy Sugar Cookie Cutouts – No Chill, No Spread

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

No reviews

Easy, no chill, no spread, sugar cookie cutouts! These classic cookies turn out perfect every time.

  • Author: Maegan
  • Prep Time: 20 minutes (plus rolling and cutting each additional batch)
  • Cook Time: 7 minutes
  • Total Time: 27 minutes
  • Yield: 36 large cookies
  • Category: dessert

Ingredients

    1. 2 cups unsalted butter, room temperature

    1. 2 cups granulated sugar

    1. 2 eggs

    1. 1 Tbsp almond emulsion (or your extract of choice)

    1. 4 tsp baking powder

    1. 6 cups all purpose flour

Instructions

    • Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

    • Start by creaming together your butter and sugar in your electric mixer with the paddle attachment.

    • Once butter and sugar is light and fluffy, add in eggs and almond emulsion, mix until combined.

    • Add in your baking powder, then add flour 2 cups at a time. Mix well each time you add flour.

    • When you’ve added your last 2 cups of flour, the dough may be stiff. You may need to take it out of your bowl and mix by hand.

    • Once dough is completely combined, lightly dust a clean work surface with flour and roll out your dough. I like to work with about 1/4 of the dough at a time. If you work with too much at one time it will be difficult to roll out.

    • Roll dough to about 1/4-1/2 inch thickness and cut with desired cookie cutters

    • Transfer to baking sheet, and bake for 6-7 minutes, depending on oven and preference. I never bake mine longer than 7 minutes. If the edges are starting to turn golden brown you’ve baked a little too long!

    • Cool completely before decorating.

Leave feedback about this Cancel Reply

Did you enjoy this recipe?

Maegan

View Comments

    • Hi Barbara - great question. I do not add any salt to these cookies. If you do prefer to add a pinch of salt you certainly can, or try using salted butter.

  • This is the best cut out sugar cookie recipe I have ever used. My Christmas cookies turned out perfect. The shapes didn’t spread and they were so delicious. Definitely using this recipe again! Thank you Maegan so much for posting this recipe!

  • Hi! I commented on your post on fb but not sure it posted. I have perhaps a dumb question. l use a recipe
    that is about half the amount of these ingredients. Is the general difference just that it basically doubles the recipe? That would make sense, but I'm always looking to try a fail proof no spread recipe!

    • Hi Natalie! Without seeing the other recipe it would be hard to know if mines is double that recipe. I can tell you this recipe makes 3-4 dozen large sugar cookie cutouts. Hope that is helpful!

  • These cookies turned out perfect! Crumbly in the mixer but then kneaded it on the counter to finish combining the ingredients and ta-da, the most perfect cookie! Soft, chewy, great flavor. Found my new cookie recipe!

  • Best cookies ever!!! Husband even likes them plain, and I fight the kids for the last one.

    Only complaint: Maegan had to limit her cookie decorating kits and how often she offered them!!! Haha

  • My family and I have enjoyed these several times and love the little kits Maegan puts together with them ! So delicious and the texture is perfect !!!

Recent Posts

Strawberries & Cream Pound Cake

Strawberries & Cream Pound Cake is a dense, buttery cake with sweet strawberry slices folded…

4 weeks ago

Easy Cake Mix Donuts

Easy cake mix donuts are perfect for holidays, birthdays, or brunches! These come together so…

2 months ago

S’mores Cookie Bars – With Marshmallow Fluff

S'mores cookie bars - with marshmallow fluff- are the perfect fall baking treat! Easy to…

2 months ago

Sailing the British Virgin Islands for 9 Nights – Itinerary, Route, & Tips

Sailing the British Virgin Islands for 9 Nights - Itinerary, Route, & Tips

2 months ago

Easy Butter Vanilla Poundcake – Perfect Every Time

Buttery, moist, and loaded with vanilla. This classic Butter Vanilla Poundcake comes out perfect every…

2 months ago

Lemon Chip Cookies with Sweet Vanilla Glaze

Lemon White Chocolate Cookies recipe - you will love this sweet and tangy cookie! Topped…

3 months ago